Baseball’s Hall of Fame Problem

Jan 28, 2021, 10:48 AM | Updated: 10:48 am
Credit: Tom Hauck  /Allsport...
Credit: Tom Hauck /Allsport

This week the Baseball Hall of Fame announced that nobody will be entering in this year’s class.

It isn’t the first time and may not be the last. In fact this is the 9th time that nobody has been elected in a single year. The question for me is why? Why not for Bonds, Clemens, and Schilling?

I am almost certain that everyone believes these guys are Hall of Famers. Bonds and Clemens have the stigma of cheating the game attached to them. I could go on and on about this and how baseball writers seem to pick and choose who they feel should be punished. 14 writers turned in empty ballots this year.

Why? You don’t have to vote for someone just to vote for someone but to me are you a Hall of Famer or not? If your reasoning for keeping them out is because you believe they cheated or you don’t like them, I think that is odd that you are the judge and jury in this situation when baseball never punished them.

There are managers in the Hall of Fame that penciled in these guys into their every game lineup. Baseball profited off the “long ball-steroid era”, yet never punished anyone at the time. Pete Rose in my opinion should be in the Hall of Fame but at least has been banned from the game. That is showing a firm decision. Bonds is allowed in baseball parks, he has been a hitting coach. His home run record is acknowledged as the record, but no Hall? The inconsistency is maddening and quite curious to me.

Listen to long time baseball announcer and historian Bob Costas here talk about what could happen soon:

Bob Costas on the Hall of Fame process

This premise also seems silly. Let me, the writer, punish them for 10 years because I think they are a Hall of Famer but I want them to suffer.

Either you are in or you are out and in this case Bonds and Clemens are no doubters. Schilling, who I am not a fan of, has a huge case and should be in as well.

Let them in.


(Photo by Mark Milan/Getty Images for Barefoot Wine )...
Carmichael Dave

Kooky Collaborations – The Carmichael Dave Show

Would you try either of these ambitious company collaborations?
7 months ago
(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)...
Carmichael Dave

Favorite Football Foods – The Carmichael Dave Show

With college and professional football season right around the corner, Dave wants to know what are some of your unique football foods?
10 months ago
Chris Watkins

Is Bugs Bunny Washed? – The Carmichael Dave Show

Is the Looney Tunes legend past his prime?
12 months ago
(Kris Connor/Getty Images)...
Carmichael Dave

What Is The Dumbest Collectable You Have Purchased? – The Carmichael Dave Show

Someone just sold a chicken nugget that looked like a video game character on EBay for $100,000, what is the dumbest collectable you've ever spent money on?
1 year ago
Boston - May 30: A man who was believed to throw a water bottle towards Kyrie Irving is escorted ou...
Jason Ross

We Can Do Better

Foolish fan behavior isn’t new at all but our reaction to this appears to be.
1 year ago
(Getty Images)...
Carmichael Dave

Will Luka and Sunday Be the Low Point?

Assuming they lose Sunday, is this the lowest point in Sacramento Kings history?
1 year ago